You won your case. The judge ruled in your favour. Then nothing happened. The other side did not pay, and did not hand over the property. This happens a lot in Pakistan. The question people ask after a court win is: what now?
The answer is execution of the decree. A decree is the formal decision of the court, as defined in section 2(2) of the Code of Civil Procedure 1908. Execution is the stage where the court makes that decision real. The rules for it sit in sections 36 to 74 and Order 21 of the same Code.
If you are at the start of this road, read our plain English guide on how to file a civil case in Pakistan. This post is about the stage after you win.
Where do you file for execution?
In the same court that passed the decree. Section 38 of the CPC says a decree is executed either by the court which passed it, or by the court to which it is sent for execution.
What if the other side has moved to another city? The decree can be transferred under section 39. That works when the debtor now lives or works in that area, or keeps property there. The court can also send the decree to another province under section 40.
How do you start?
In most of Pakistan you file a written execution application. Order 21 rule 11 lists what it must carry: the case number, the names of the parties, the date of the decree, the amount still due, whether an appeal was filed, and the exact help you want from the court. You also attach a certified copy of the decree.
Punjab changed this in 2021. Under the Code of Civil Procedure (Punjab Amendment) Ordinance 2021, the suit file itself becomes the execution case when an executable decree is passed. No separate application and no fresh notice to the debtor is needed there. The amended text of Order 21 shows the change.
In the other provinces, if your application comes more than one year after the decree, or you are executing against the legal heirs of a debtor, the court first issues a notice to show cause under Order 21 rule 22.
Can the other side object?
Yes, but for a money decree there is a condition. Under Order 21 rule 23A, the court will not hear the objection unless the debtor first deposits the decretal amount in court, or gives security for it. So a debtor cannot delay execution forever by filing objections.
What can the court do?
Section 51 lists the tools. The court can deliver the property that the decree gave you. It can attach and sell the debtor's property. It can arrest and detain the debtor. It can appoint a receiver. Or it can use any other way that fits the relief.
For a money decree, Order 21 rule 30 allows both at once: detention in prison and attachment and sale of property.
What can be attached?
Most property can be attached. Section 60 of the CPC covers land, houses, goods, money, bank notes, cheques, debts and shares.
A bank account is attached under Order 21 rule 46. The court sends an order to the bank. The bank must not pay the debtor. The bank can pay the money into court instead.
Some things are protected and cannot be attached. Section 60 lists them. Wearing apparel, cooking vessels, beds and bedding. Tools of artisans. A farmer's implements, cattle and seed grain, and the house of an agriculturist. Account books. Wages of labourers and domestic servants. Pensions and provident fund money. The first one hundred rupees of salary and half of the rest. Army pay. A right to future maintenance.
Can the debtor be arrested?
Only in limited cases. Section 51 says detention is not ordered unless the court records in writing that the debtor is likely to run away, or has secretly transferred or hidden property, or has the means to pay and still refuses.
Before a warrant of arrest, the court gives the debtor one chance to show cause, under Order 21 rule 37. If the debtor is arrested, the officer brings him before the court. Paying the amount at the time of arrest gets him released at once under section 55.
Detention is simple imprisonment for up to one year. Imprisonment does not cancel the debt. And women cannot be arrested in execution of a money decree. Section 56 says so.
How does the sale work?
If the money stays unpaid, the court can sell the attached property. Sales are by public auction, after a proclamation, under Order 21 rules 65 and 66.
The sale does not stay final forever. A person with an interest in the property can apply to set it aside within 30 days under rule 89, by depositing the decretal amount plus 5 per cent of the purchase money. A sale can also be set aside for material irregularity or fraud under rule 90, if it caused real loss. The 30 day limit comes from article 166 of the Limitation Act 1908.
How much time do you have?
Do not wait years. The old rule allowed twelve years to execute a decree. That article was removed from the Limitation Act 1908.
Today the general article 181 applies. It gives three years from the day the right to apply arises. Decrees of a High Court in its original jurisdiction, and orders of the Supreme Court, get six years under article 183.
Section 48 of the CPC adds another limit. No fresh execution application is entertained after six years from the date of the decree, except where the debtor hid the property by fraud or force.
What if the debtor dies?
Execution continues against the legal heirs. Under section 50, they are liable only to the extent of the deceased person's property that actually came into their hands.
Who decides disputes during execution?
The executing court itself. Section 47 says all questions about the execution, discharge or satisfaction of the decree are decided by that court, not through a fresh lawsuit.
What should you do next?
Get a certified copy of the decree. File the execution application in the court that passed it. If you know a specific asset, name it, like a bank account or a plot of land. Keep the application alive within the time limits. If the debtor has no assets you can find, tell the court. The court can summon the debtor and ask how the decree will be paid.
Winning is not the end. Execution is where the win becomes money. The law gives the court strong tools. Use them before time runs out.
The earlier stage of the same fight is covered in our guide on the legal routes to recover money from someone in Pakistan. And since every step in court costs something, see our guide on court fees in Pakistan.
For more plain English legal guides, visit the Lexiber blog. You can also browse the Lexiber home page for the full list of topics.
Ask Lexiber free in English or Urdu. It shows you the exact section behind every answer.
